IEvidence from epidemiological
studies seems to show consistently that intake of dietary fat and meat
is positively related to risk of colorectal cancer. This evidence is obtained
from ecological studies, animal experiments, and case-control and cohort
studies.
In 1990 Willett et
al published the results from the US nurses health study involving follow
up of 88 751 women aged 34-59 years who were without cancer or inflammatory
bowel disease at recruitment. After adjustment for total energy intake,
consumption of animal fat was found to be associated with increased risk
of colon cancer. The trend in risk was highly significant (P = 0.01), with
the relative risk in the highest compared with the lowest quintile being
1.89 (95% confidence interval 1.13 to 3.15). No association was found with
vegetable fat. The relative risk in women who ate beef, pork, or lamb as
a main dish every day was 2.49 (1.24 to 5.03) compared with women reporting
consumption less than once a month. The authors suggested that their data
supported the hypothesis that high intake of animal fat increases the risk
of colon cancer, and they supported existing recommendations to substitute
fish Figure 1.5 Intake of dietary fat and meat may increase risk of colorectal
cancer and chicken for meats high in fat.
Intake of vegetables,
fruit, and fibre
Dietary fibre has been
proposed as accounting for the differences in the rates of colorectal cancer
between Africa and westernised countries-on the basis that increased intake
of dietary fibre may increase faecal bulk and reduce transit time. Various
other factors, related to risk of colorectal cancer, are now thought to
contribute to explaining these differences.
Fibre has many components,
each of which has specific physiological functions. The components are
most commonly grouped into insoluble, non-degradable constituents (mainly
found in cereal fibre) and soluble, degradable constituents, such as pectin
and plant gums (mainly found in fruits and vegetables). Epidemiological
studies have reported differences in the effect of these components. Many
studies, however, found no protective effect of fibre in cereals but have
consistently found a protective effect of fibre in vegetables and perhaps
. Fruits are a good source of fibre and may protect against cancer of fruits
and vegetables, with fibre intake acting merely as an indicator of consumption.
|